完整范文
题目
Some people argue that the government should pay the full cost of public transport, so that buses and trains are free for every citizen. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
Some argue that buses and trains should be funded entirely through taxes, so that every citizen can travel at no charge. I agree that the government has a duty to keep public transport affordable, but I believe free travel should be targeted at the people who need it most rather than offered to everyone.
1 开头把立场拆成两层:同意政府有责任让公共交通负担得起,反对“人人免费”这种做法,改为定向免费。程度和边界在第二句就定下来了。
Public transport is a clear case of public benefit, which is why the state should pay a large share of its cost. Every full bus means dozens of cars off the road, so the whole city gains from lower congestion and cleaner air, including residents who rarely take the bus. Fares also fall hardest on low-income workers, who often live far from their jobs; a cleaner who spends a fifth of her wage on travel has less left for food and rent. Because these gains are shared by society, it is reasonable for taxpayers to share the cost.
2 这一段回答“为什么是政府的责任”:公共交通的好处覆盖全城,包括很少坐公交的人,所以由纳税人分担成本是合理的。清洁工的例子把低收入群体写具体,末句把公共利益和税收连起来。
However, making transport free for all would be an expensive way to reach these goals. In a large city, fares can cover around a third of running costs, and replacing that income would require higher taxes or cuts elsewhere, for example to hospitals or schools. Much of the subsidy would also go to commuters who can easily afford their tickets. A more efficient policy is to give free passes to students, pensioners and low-income families, keep modest fares for everyone else, and spend the savings on more frequent services, which draw drivers out of their cars more effectively than a zero price.
3 这一段写取舍:钱从哪里来(加税或削减医院、学校预算),钱流向了谁(本来就买得起票的通勤者)。最后给出替代方案和理由:定向免费加提高班次,比票价归零更能让人放弃开车。
In conclusion, the government should certainly fund public transport generously, since its benefits reach the whole city. Yet the wisest use of public money is targeted free travel combined with better services, rather than free tickets for every passenger.
4 结尾用 certainly 重申同意的部分,用 Yet 重申边界,和开头的两层立场一一对应,全段只做收束,论点都来自前文。
293 词 · 为什么这样写
这篇范文写清了钱从哪里来、挤占了哪些预算,论证就超出了“政府应该花钱”的口号。部分同意的立场从开头到结尾守着同一个边界,Task Response 因此稳定。
照着这篇范文打一遍 →
政府类论证的三个问题
动笔前给每个主体段的观点回答三个问题:为什么由政府来做、哪一群人受益多少、钱从哪里来又挤占了什么,政府类论证就有了公共利益和取舍。下面三句英文各对应一问,可以换成你的话题。
- Because the benefits are shared by the whole community, the cost should be shared through taxation.
- The people who gain most are low-income families, for whom this cost takes a large part of monthly income.
- Every dollar spent here is a dollar taken from hospitals or schools, so the policy must be targeted.
下一步
照这篇的结构,写一篇全文
点开就是题目和模板,现在就能写。登录后检查通过可以获取评分,每个账号可以免费评一篇。