半分写作

雅思大作文学生校服:从第一稿到范文

一道问“好还是不好”的观点题。先看一篇 243 词的第一稿卡在哪三处,再看同一组想法改成 308 词以后怎样从开头就回答题目,并把理由讲到校服本身。

作者:Hans · 更新于 先读清题目,再写完整作文。
完整范文
题目

In many countries, schools require every student to wear a uniform. Do you think this is a positive or a negative rule for students?

第一稿 · 243 词

Nowadays many schools around the world ask their students to wear a uniform every day. Students, parents and teachers often have different ideas about this rule. Some of them support it strongly, while others are against it. This essay will look at the effects of this rule on students.

Firstly, a uniform is good for the relationships between students. When all students wear the same clothes, they are equal. This is very important for young people. At the secondary school my cousin attends, every student wears a white shirt and dark blue trousers, and she told me that she likes this rule. She also said that getting ready for school takes her only five minutes because she has nothing to choose.

Secondly, a uniform improves discipline. When students put on the uniform in the morning, they understand that the school day has started, so they are more ready to follow the rules in class. Teachers also spend less time arguing with students about suitable clothes. However, some parents say that uniforms are too expensive and that teenagers cannot show their personality. These complaints are common in many countries, especially among families with several children.

In conclusion, school uniforms have a strong influence on the daily life of students. They make students equal and help them to behave well in class, although some families are unhappy about the price. For these reasons, I think that the uniform rule is a positive one for students.

这一稿卡在哪
  1. This essay will look at the effects of this rule on students.

    题目问的是这条规定对学生好还是不好,开头的最后一句只预告了要写什么。读者要读到全文最后一句才知道作者的答案,中间两段读的时候不知道它们在支持哪一边。

    怎么改 把这句换成你的答案:写明是好的规定,并用半句话带出两个理由。

  2. When all students wear the same clothes, they are equal.

    这句话只给了结论。读者不知道没有校服时学生之间的差别是什么,也不知道穿一样的衣服怎样消除它。后面表妹的例子只说她喜欢这条规定、早上省时间,没有接回“平等”。

    怎么改 写出过程:自己选衣服时,衣服会显出家里的收入,穿得旧的学生会被取笑;穿校服以后这个差别看不出来。让表妹的例子说明这一点。

  3. However, some parents say that uniforms are too expensive and that teenagers cannot show their personality.

    这里提出了反对一方的两个顾虑,下一句只说这种抱怨很常见,然后段落就结束了。读者不知道作者怎样看待费用和个性,这两个顾虑留在文中,反而削弱了“好的规定”这个结论。

    怎么改 单独用一段回应:先承认校服要花钱,再比较一套校服和一年便服的花费;个性可以在周末的穿着和学校的社团、发言里表现。

改后的一稿
  1. Many schools require every student to wear the same uniform, and families often disagree about whether this rule helps young people. In my view it is a positive rule for students, because it hides differences in family income and marks a clear start to the school day, provided that the school keeps the uniform simple and affordable.

    开头:直接回答 第二句用 it is a positive rule for students 直接回答了题目,because 后面带出两个理由,provided that 留了一个条件(校服要简单、买得起)。第一稿到结尾才出现的答案,现在在开头。

  2. The main benefit is that a uniform hides how much money each family has. Where students choose their own clothes, a teenager in expensive trainers and a branded jacket sits next to one who wears the same old coat every day, and the second student is often teased or left out. At the secondary school my cousin attends, everyone wears a white shirt and dark blue trousers, and she says that nobody in her class can tell whose parents earn more. The same clothes also support discipline in a practical way: putting them on signals that the school day has begun, and teachers spend less time arguing about what counts as suitable clothing.

    两个理由 第一稿的“穿一样的衣服就平等”在这里有了过程:自己选衣服时,名牌外套和旧外套坐在一起,穿旧外套的学生被取笑;穿校服以后,表妹班上没有人看得出谁家收入高。表妹的例子现在说明的是平等。纪律的理由保留了第一稿的解释。

  3. Critics raise two fair concerns, namely cost and personal expression. A uniform does cost money, but two shirts and two pairs of trousers bought from an ordinary shop are cheaper than a year of fashionable outfits, and many schools run a second-hand sale for families who need it. As for expression, students still choose their own clothes at weekends, and at school they can show who they are through their clubs, their hobbies and the opinions they give in class.

    回应反对的顾虑 第一稿提到费用和个性以后就停了,这一段逐个回应。费用:先用 does cost money 承认,再拿两件衬衫、两条裤子和一年的时髦衣服比较,并补上二手校服。个性:周末的穿着、社团、爱好和课堂上的发言。

  4. In conclusion, I believe that requiring a uniform is a positive rule for students, since it prevents clothes from dividing a class by income and helps the school day start in an orderly way. This holds as long as schools choose plain items that any family can buy cheaply, rather than expensive designs sold by a single supplier.

    结尾:重申答案和条件 第一句重申答案,并用 since 把两个理由各说一遍。第二句的 as long as 把开头留的条件写完整:学校选普通款式,每个家庭都能便宜买到。结尾里的内容都来自前文。

308 词 · 为什么这样写

改后的一稿和第一稿用的是同一组想法,差别在三处:答案从结尾挪到了开头,“平等”有了从衣服到家庭收入的过程,费用和个性这两个顾虑得到了回应。问“好还是不好”的题目,第一段就要给出答案,后面每一段都为这个答案服务。

话题词
provided that
只要、在……的条件下
affordable
价格在承受范围内
family income
家庭收入
branded jacket
名牌外套
left out
被排除在外、受冷落
suitable clothing
合适的着装
personal expression
个性的表达
second-hand sale
二手物品售卖

照着这篇范文打一遍 →

自己写

正在打开题目

常见陷阱

只写 uniforms make students equal,却没有说明 equal 指什么。

审题时先问什么

先判断题目问 discipline、cost、belonging 还是 personal freedom。

同一类题,还可能这样问

下面三道题都问一项规定或变化是好是坏。第一段就写出答案,后面的段落都为这个答案服务。

  • Some schools ban mobile phones during the whole school day. Do you think this is a positive or a negative rule for students?
  • In some countries, children start school at the age of four. Is this a positive or a negative development?
  • More schools now give homework that must be completed on a computer. Do you think this is a positive or a negative change?
下一步

照这篇的结构,写一篇全文

点开就是题目和模板,现在就能写。登录后检查通过可以获取评分,每个账号可以免费评一篇。