常见陷阱
只写 AI will take jobs,会忽略不同职业和再培训。
一道讨论双方的大作文题。先看一篇 250 词的第一稿卡在哪三处,再看同一组想法改成 296 词以后怎样把两种看法都讲完整。
Some people believe that artificial intelligence will take away more jobs than it creates. Others think it will mainly change the kind of work people do. Discuss both views and give your own opinion.
Nowadays artificial intelligence is developing very fast around the world and many people are worried about their jobs. It is one of the most discussed topics today. Some people think that AI will take away more jobs than it creates, while others believe that it will only change the work people do. This essay will discuss both views.
On the one hand, AI will replace many workers. Machines are cheaper and faster than humans, so companies will prefer to use them. A lot of people will lose their jobs and it will be a big problem for society. For example, many factories now use robots instead of workers, and some shops have machines where customers pay by themselves. A supermarket near my home opened four of these machines last year, and now there are fewer cashiers than before. Drivers may also be replaced when cars can drive themselves.
On the other hand, some people say that AI will only change jobs. They think new jobs will appear in the future, and companies will need workers who understand the new technology. This idea is too optimistic, because not everyone can learn new skills. Older workers and people with little education will find it difficult to study computers.
In conclusion, artificial intelligence has both advantages and disadvantages for employment. Some jobs will disappear and some new jobs will appear, as has happened with every new technology in history. In my opinion, the government and individuals should work together to solve this problem.
A lot of people will lose their jobs and it will be a big problem for society.
第一个观点停在结论上。读者不知道是哪一类工作、为什么会被替代、被替代的人之后怎样,后面的工厂和商店只是现象,没有接回这句话。
怎么改 选一类工作写完整:哪些任务能被自动化,岗位因此减少多少,这些人为什么难以马上转到别处。
This idea is too optimistic, because not everyone can learn new skills.
题目要求讨论两种观点,第二种只讲了一句就被否定。这一方为什么有人相信,文中没有交代,两边的篇幅和力度差得很远。
怎么改 先替这一方把理由讲完整,给一个新岗位或工作内容变化的例子,再指出它成立的条件。
In my opinion, the government and individuals should work together to solve this problem.
题目问的是你更同意哪一种看法,结尾给出的是一条建议。全文读完,读者仍然不知道作者站在哪一边。
怎么改 在开头就写明倾向,结尾用一句话重申,并说明这个判断在什么条件下成立。
As artificial intelligence spreads through offices and factories, people disagree about what it will do to employment. Some fear that it will destroy more jobs than it creates, while others expect it mainly to change how work is done. I believe the second view is closer to the truth, although the change will be painful for many workers unless they are helped through it.
开头 第三句直接回答题目:更同意第二种看法,同时留了一个条件(工人需要帮助才能度过转变)。立场和边界在开头就定了。
Those who expect large job losses point to the routine tasks that software already performs. A program can now sort invoices, answer simple customer questions and check documents faster than a clerk, and it does not need a salary. When a bank automates these tasks, it may need far fewer people in its back office, and a clerk in her fifties cannot simply become a software engineer the following month. For workers like her, the fear of being displaced is realistic.
第一种看法 这一段把第一稿里的那句结论展开了:哪些任务(整理发票、回答简单问题、核对文件)、为什么被替代(更快、不用发工资)、之后怎样(五十多岁的职员没法马上转行)。末句承认这种担心有道理。
However, supporters of the other view argue that most jobs are bundles of tasks, and AI usually removes only some of them. An accountant who no longer enters figures by hand has more time to advise clients, and a radiologist can let software mark suspicious scans while she concentrates on the difficult cases. New roles also appear, such as people who train, test and oversee these systems. In this sense the work is transformed rather than eliminated, but only for those who are able to retrain.
第二种看法 第二种看法得到和第一种同样的篇幅:先讲理由(一份工作是一组任务,AI 只拿走其中一部分),再给会计和放射科医生两个例子,然后是新岗位。末句的 but only for 写出了它成立的条件。
In conclusion, although AI will remove many routine posts in the short term, I agree more with the view that it will reshape work than with the view that it will leave people with nothing to do. Whether this transition is fair depends on governments and employers paying for retraining, so that the workers who lose routine tasks can move into the roles that remain.
结尾 结尾先让一步(短期内确实会减少常规岗位),再重申更同意哪一边,最后一句把开头留的条件写完整:谁来出钱培训,培训之后去哪里。全段只做收束,论点都来自前文。
改后的一稿和第一稿用的是同一组想法,差别在三处:立场从结尾挪到了开头,第一种看法有了任务、原因和后果,第二种看法得到了同样的篇幅和一个成立条件。讨论双方的题目,两边都要有人替它把话说完。
正在打开题目
只写 AI will take jobs,会忽略不同职业和再培训。
先判断题目问 job loss、productivity、education response 还是 government policy。
下面三道题都要求讨论双方,话题仍是科技与工作。动笔前先定好更同意哪一边,再给两边同样的篇幅。
点开就是题目和模板,现在就能写。登录后检查通过可以获取评分,每个账号可以免费评一篇。