为什么观点相关,Task Response 仍然偏低
公开的评分标准里,Task Response 的分数和立场的清晰度直接挂钩,观点切题只是起点。立场一摇摆,相关的观点也会像一堆材料,Task Response 停在 6 分附近。
- 7 分:立场在全文中始终清楚
- 6 分:立场相关,结论可能变得含糊或重复
- 5 分:有立场,展开只是时而清楚
很多文章观点大体切题,但立场在开头、主体段和结论之间摇摆,Task Response 就显得飘。
题目问 to what extent,答案却只写“有好有坏”。
两段分别支持不同方向,最终判断却还悬着。
结尾出现新的判断,让读者重新解读全文。
立场是对题目问法的回答,所以先看问法要什么。to what extent 要一个程度(完全、大体或部分同意),outweigh 要一个比较结果,discuss both views and give your opinion 要一个倾向,两问题要两个答案。
Some people believe that universities should make all of their lectures available online, free of charge. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
动笔前先写一句完整的立场句,包含程度词和最主要的理由,后面每一段都回来对照它。程度词选一个就固定下来,largely agree 和 strongly agree 是两个立场。
I largely agree, because free online lectures open university knowledge to anyone with an internet connection.
部分同意只设一条边界,用一个短语写清楚:provided that、except for、as long as。边界写在开头,主体段和结尾重复同样的意思,读者就知道你同意哪部分、保留哪部分。
I largely agree that lectures should be free online, provided that seminars, lab work and assessment remain part of a paid, in-person degree.
每个主体段的第一句都说明这一段支持立场的哪一部分。写完后只读立场句和各段第一句,这三四句连起来是一篇完整的小论证,立场就清楚了,只在谈话题的那一句改写成对立场的支持。
The strongest reason to publish lectures freely is that it removes cost and distance as barriers to learning.
同意或反对题里,对方观点用让步句写:先承认,再说明它只小幅改变你的结论。这样整段仍在为你的立场服务。
Admittedly, universities earn income from tuition, yet the lectures are only a small part of what students pay for, which is why the hands-on parts of a degree should stay paid.
立场摇摆常出在用词上,开头 largely agree,中间 completely right,结尾又成了 it depends。选定程度词和边界短语后全文都用这一组词,检查时圈出所有表达态度的词,强度要一致。
This largely positive view holds as long as the practical side of education keeps its place on campus.
结尾用开头的程度词和边界重申立场,再用一句概括主要理由。新的判断、新的条件和新的例子都应该在正文里,结尾只把读者带回开头那句话。
In conclusion, I largely agree that university lectures should be free online, as long as the practical and assessed parts of a degree remain on campus.
正在打开题目
公开的评分标准里,Task Response 的分数和立场的清晰度直接挂钩,观点切题只是起点。立场一摇摆,相关的观点也会像一堆材料,Task Response 停在 6 分附近。
改前的开头列出了两边,读者还要猜你的答案,改后的开头用一个程度词和一条边界回答了 to what extent。
点开就是题目和模板,现在就能写。登录后检查通过可以获取评分,每个账号可以免费评一篇。