半分写作

雅思大作文垃圾食品税:从第一稿到范文

一道两问的大作文题。先看一篇 249 词的第一稿卡在哪三处,再看同一组想法改成 293 词以后怎样把两个问题都答完整。

作者:Hans · 更新于 先读清题目,再写完整作文。
常见陷阱

只说 tax makes people healthier,却没有解释低收入人群或替代选择。

完整范文
题目

In some countries, the government has added a tax to sugary drinks and fast food. Why do governments introduce a tax of this kind? Do you think it is an effective way to improve public health?

第一稿 · 249 词

Nowadays more and more people eat fast food and drink sugary drinks every day, and this has become a common habit in many cities. In some countries the government has added a tax to these products. This essay will explain why governments do this and whether it is an effective way to improve public health.

There are several reasons why governments introduce this kind of tax. The first reason is that unhealthy food causes many health problems. People who eat too much sugar and fat can become overweight, and later they may have diabetes or heart disease. Children are also affected, because many of them drink cola after school instead of water. The second reason is money. Public hospitals have to treat these patients for many years, and this costs the government a lot. A tax can bring in extra money to pay for health care. In addition, a tax shows people that the government cares about this problem, so it is also a kind of education.

As for the second question, I think this tax is effective because it is good for the health of the public. When the price is higher, everyone will stop buying these products.

In conclusion, governments tax sugary drinks and fast food because these products make people ill and cost hospitals a lot of money. Unhealthy eating is a serious problem in modern society, and it is getting worse every year. I hope that more countries will introduce this tax in the future.

这一稿卡在哪
  1. As for the second question, I think this tax is effective because it is good for the health of the public.

    题目问这项税有没有效,这句话的理由是「对健康有好处」,等于把问题重说了一遍。读者看不出加税以后人们买的东西怎样变化。第一问写了八句,第二问全段只有两句。

    怎么改 把第二问写成和第一问一样长的一段,用一件具体商品讲清过程:价格高了多少,谁因此改买别的,糖的摄入怎样减少。

  2. When the price is higher, everyone will stop buying these products.

    「所有人都不再买」说得太满。读者不知道税主要落在谁身上,继续买的人多付了多少,也不知道不买的人改买了什么。收入低的家庭和替代品,全文都没有提到。

    怎么改 分开写两类人:对价格敏感的人会少买,预算紧的家庭可能照样买、只是多花钱。再补一句人们可能改买什么。

  3. In conclusion, governments tax sugary drinks and fast food because these products make people ill and cost hospitals a lot of money.

    结尾只总结了第一问的原因。「是否有效」在结尾没有答案,后两句写的是问题有多严重和一个希望,读者读完仍然不知道作者的判断。

    怎么改 结尾用一句话答第一问,再用一句话答第二问,并写明这项税在什么条件下有效。

改后的一稿
  1. Several countries now tax sugary drinks and fast food. Governments do this mainly to reduce the illness that a poor diet causes and to cover part of the cost of treating it. I believe such a tax can improve public health to a limited extent, provided that healthier choices are within reach of the people who pay it.

    开头 第二句答第一问(减少疾病、分担治疗费用),第三句答第二问:有效,但程度有限,条件是 healthier choices are within reach。第一稿的开头只预告要写什么,这里两个问题在开头就各有一句答案。

  2. The main reason for the tax is that cheap food high in sugar and fat is linked to weight gain, diabetes and heart disease. Children are a particular concern, since many buy a can of cola on the way home from school. The second reason is financial. Public hospitals treat these conditions for many years, and the bill falls on every taxpayer. A tax makes the buyers of these products contribute to that cost.

    第一问:为什么加税 保留了第一稿的两个原因(健康和钱),删掉了「加税也是一种教育」那一句,篇幅让给第二问。the bill falls on every taxpayer 把「政府花很多钱」说成了具体由谁承担。

  3. Whether the tax works depends on how shoppers respond to the higher price. If a can of cola costs noticeably more than a bottle of water, some people, especially teenagers with little pocket money, will choose the water. In this way a tax can reduce how much sugar people consume. However, the effect is uneven. A family on a tight budget feels the tax most, and if fresh vegetables remain more expensive than a burger, that family may simply pay more for the same meals. Others may switch to untaxed products, such as sweet biscuits, that are no healthier.

    第二问:是否有效 这一段修了第一稿的前两个问题。前三句讲清价格怎样起作用:可乐比水贵,零花钱少的中学生改买水,糖的摄入减少。However 之后写谁在付这笔税(a family on a tight budget)和人们改买什么(sweet biscuits),取代了「所有人都不再买」。篇幅也比第一问略长。

  4. In conclusion, governments tax unhealthy food both to protect people from diet-related illness and to recover some of the cost of treating it. I think the tax is partly effective: it lowers consumption among people who are sensitive to price, but it improves public health more widely only if the money raised is used to make healthy food affordable for low-income families.

    结尾 第一句答第一问,第二句答第二问,修了第一稿结尾只答一问的问题。partly effective 是明确的判断,only if 之后把开头留的条件写完整:税收要用来让低收入家庭买得起健康食品。

293 词 · 为什么这样写

改后的一稿和第一稿用的是同一组想法,差别在三处:第二问从两句话变成了完整的一段,「有效」有了价格怎样改变购买的过程和谁在付税的限制,结尾对两个问题各给了一句答案。两问的题目,每一问都要有自己的段落、自己的理由和结尾里的一句回答。

话题词
a poor diet
不健康的饮食
within reach of
(某人)买得到、买得起
be linked to
与……有关联
the bill falls on
费用由……承担
consume
吃、喝,摄入
on a tight budget
预算很紧
switch to
改买、改用
sensitive to price
对价格变化反应明显

照着这篇范文打一遍 →

自己写

正在打开题目

审题时先问什么

先判断题目问 government responsibility、personal freedom、health cost 还是 fairness。

同一类题,还可能这样问

下面三道题都有两问。给每一问一个完整的段落,结尾各用一句话回答。

  • In many cities, more people are overweight than twenty years ago. Why is this happening? What can governments do about it?
  • Some governments ban advertisements for fast food during television programmes for children. Why do they do this? Do you think it is an effective measure?
  • In some countries, cigarettes are sold in plain packets with health warnings. Why have governments introduced this rule? Is it an effective way to reduce smoking?
下一步

照这篇的结构,写一篇全文

点开就是题目和模板,现在就能写。登录后检查通过可以获取评分,每个账号可以免费评一篇。