审题时先问什么
先定一个角度:价格、便利、身份认同或媒体曝光。
- 消费者动机是否出现
- 本地文化是否具体
- 影响是替代还是融合
一道利弊比较的大作文题。先看一篇 246 词的第一稿卡在哪三处,再看同一组想法改成 300 词以后怎样把好处和代价比出轻重。
只批评 multinational companies,忽略消费者为什么愿意改变。
International brands and chain stores now sell the same food, drinks and clothes in almost every country. Do the advantages of this development outweigh the disadvantages?
Nowadays the same international brands can be found in almost every country. People can buy the same burgers, coffee and clothes in many different cities around the world. This development has some advantages and some disadvantages. This essay will discuss both sides.
On the one hand, global brands bring many benefits. First, people know these brands and they trust them. This is good for customers and it makes their lives more convenient. Second, international chains create jobs for local people. When a big clothing shop or a fast food restaurant opens in a city, it needs many workers, so young people can find work there easily. The prices are also sometimes lower than in small shops because big companies produce a lot of products.
On the other hand, there are also disadvantages. The main one is that local culture will be damaged when global brands arrive. For example, a famous coffee chain opened a shop near my university last year and it is always full of students. Many of my classmates go there every week to study and talk with friends. In addition, small local shops cannot compete with big companies, so some of them have to close. Then every city will look the same, which is boring for tourists.
In conclusion, international brands have both advantages and disadvantages. They give people convenience and jobs, but they also affect local shops and traditions. In my opinion, people should think carefully about both sides of this development.
This is good for customers and it makes their lives more convenient.
这个好处停在结论上。读者不知道顾客信任品牌以后具体省了什么事,在什么场合用得上,「方便」两个字没有内容。
怎么改 写一个具体的顾客和场合:他走进一家熟悉的连锁店时已经知道哪些事,因此少冒了什么风险。
For example, a famous coffee chain opened a shop near my university last year and it is always full of students.
例子和论点没有接上。前一句说本地文化会受损,这个例子只说明咖啡店生意好,读者看不出哪一样本地的东西因此消失了。
怎么改 把例子写到本地那一方:学生原来去哪家店,那家店卖什么,连锁店开张以后它怎样了。
In my opinion, people should think carefully about both sides of this development.
题目问的是好处是否大于坏处,结尾两边都没有选。全文读完,读者仍然不知道作者认为哪一边更重。
怎么改 在开头就写明哪一边更重,结尾重申一次,并用一句话说明比较的理由。
The same coffee chains, fast food restaurants and clothing shops now appear on high streets in almost every country. This brings real benefits to shoppers and workers, but I believe the disadvantages are greater, because these brands gradually push out the local businesses that make one place different from another.
开头 第二句直接回答题目:I believe the disadvantages are greater,后面的 because 给出比较的理由(本地店铺被挤走)。第一稿到结尾都没有选边,这里在开头就定了。
The main advantage is that customers know what they will get. A traveller who walks into a familiar burger restaurant in a foreign city already knows the menu, the price and the standard of hygiene, so she does not have to take a risk on a dish she cannot name. International chains also employ local people, and a large clothing shop may take on dozens of young staff when it opens. These gains are real, although a city could also get reliable food and new jobs from its own businesses.
好处 第一稿的「方便」在这里有了内容:一位在外国城市的旅客,已经知道 the menu, the price and the standard of hygiene,所以少冒一次风险。末句的 although 提前为比较做准备:这些好处从别处也能得到。
However, the cost to local culture is much harder to repair. When a coffee chain opened near my university, students gained a comfortable place to study, but they stopped going to the family-run tea house on the same street, which closed within a year. That tea house served a local tea and a steamed snack that the chain does not sell, and the owner had learned to make them from her mother. When shops like this close, the recipes and skills go with them. If this is repeated street by street, every city comes to look the same, and visitors find little they could not see at home.
代价 同一个咖啡店的例子,这次写到了本地那一方:学生不再去 the family-run tea house,它一年内关门,the recipes and skills go with them。第一稿的例子只说咖啡店人多,现在读者能看到失去的是什么。
In conclusion, global brands offer convenience and some employment, but people can obtain these in other ways, while a lost food tradition does not come back. For this reason I think the disadvantages outweigh the advantages, unless cities protect space for local businesses, for example by keeping rents low for family-run shops.
结尾 结尾把两边放在一起比:好处 can obtain these in other ways,代价 does not come back,然后用题目里的 outweigh 重申立场。unless 一句写出这个判断在什么条件下会改变。
改后的一稿和第一稿用的是同一组想法,差别在三处:立场在开头就写明,「方便」换成了一位旅客知道的三件事,咖啡店的例子写到了关门的茶馆。利弊比较的题目要求给出轻重,所以每一边写完以后,还要有一句话说明它为什么更重或更轻。
正在打开题目
先定一个角度:价格、便利、身份认同或媒体曝光。
下面三道题都要比较利弊。动笔前先决定哪一边更重,并准备一句说明理由的话。
点开就是题目和模板,现在就能写。登录后检查通过可以获取评分,每个账号可以免费评一篇。