半分写作

Task Response 先问:你到底是否回答了题。

很多作文看起来有观点、有例子、有段落,但只回答了题目的一部分。检查 Task Response 要先看题目要求是否完成。

作者:Hans · 更新于 语言表达排在任务完成之后。
覆盖题目要求

讨论双方、给出立场、解释原因或提出方案,题目要什么就必须完成什么。

主要观点要展开

只有 topic sentence 还差得远,还要解释为什么、怎么发生、结果是什么。

评分标准

Task Response 是 Task 2 的第一项评分标准,看你是否答全了题目的每一部分,立场是否始终清楚。6 分和 7 分差在程度:6 分档有的部分一笔带过,7 分档每一部分都有实质回答。

  • 这样写读起来

    Question: Why do many young adults now live with their parents for longer, and is this a positive or negative development? — Body paragraph 2: Another reason is that house prices are very high in big cities, so young people struggle to afford to move out.

    改成这样

    Body paragraph 2: On balance, this is a positive development for most families, because sharing a home lets young adults save a deposit faster while parents gain help with daily costs and care.

    两问题要两个答案。左边第二个主体段还在写原因,「好还是坏」只在结尾出现一句,这是 6 分的「有的部分覆盖较少」,右边让第二段整段回答第二问。

  • 这样写读起来

    Question: Some people think museums should be free for children. — Free museums are good for society because everyone can learn about history and culture.

    改成这样

    Free entry matters most for children from lower-income families, whose parents may skip a paid visit, so a free ticket can decide whether a child sees a museum at all.

    题目的对象是「儿童」,左边悄悄换成了「所有人」,论证偏离了题目范围。右边每个名词都留在题目里(儿童、家庭、门票),这正是 7 分要求的切中题目范围。

  • 这样写读起来

    Working from home has many benefits: it saves time, reduces stress and lowers costs.

    改成这样

    The clearest benefit of working from home is the time saved on commuting: an employee who used to spend ninety minutes a day on trains gains seven and a half hours a week, which many people put into exercise or family time.

    左边一句列了三个好处,每个都只有一个名词,这是 6 分的「观点切题但展开偏少」。右边只留一个好处,写出数量、机制和结果,就成了 7 分的「展开并有支撑」。

  • 这样写读起来

    Everyone who works from home becomes more productive, because colleagues stop interrupting them.

    改成这样

    Many office workers who handle focused tasks, such as writing reports or coding, become more productive at home, since they face fewer interruptions from colleagues.

    「每个人」「从来」这类全称说法,考官一想到反例就会打折。右边把范围收窄到「做专注型工作的办公室员工」,判断更准确,也更容易用例子证明,改掉的正是 7 分档常见的概括过宽。

  • 这样写读起来

    Question: Should cities ban cars from their centres? — Example: For example, many people in my city drive cars every day and the roads are very busy.

    改成这样

    Example: When one city closed four central streets to cars on weekends, the shops there reported more visitors on foot, which suggests a car-free centre can support local business.

    左边的例子只说明「车多」,和「市中心限车有好处」之间还隔着一步。右边的例子直接演示了主张:限车 → 步行人数增加 → 商店受益。

  • 这样写读起来

    Conclusion: In conclusion, online learning has advantages and disadvantages, and it also depends on the student’s personality and the subject.

    改成这样

    Conclusion: In conclusion, online courses suit adult learners who need flexible hours, but school pupils still benefit more from face-to-face teaching, as argued above.

    左边的结论换成了「各有利弊」,还加了正文里第一次出现的「性格」,这是 6 分的「结论含糊、带入新观点」。右边用一句话重述正文已经论证过的判断,和开头立场一致。

Task Response 靠审题,模板帮助有限

模板能帮你组织答案,题目要回答什么还得你自己判断。先审题,再决定每段职责。

交卷前三分钟的 Task Response 自查

交卷前用三分钟,每分钟查一项,三项都对得上,这篇作文就有了 7 分档 Task Response 的骨架。

  • 第一分钟:重读题目,给每个问句或要求编号,在作文里找到回答它的那一段
  • 第二分钟:只读每个主体段第一句和它的例子,确认例子证明的是这一句
  • 第三分钟:读结论,确认判断都在正文论证过,用词和开头立场一致
下一步

用自己的几句英文检查这一项

写 2–3 句英文拿一份反馈,再按本页的检查点改一版。游客也能试,登录后保留记录。