常见风险
只写 volunteering is good,会忽略 unpaid、compulsory 和 student workload 的争议。
一道同意与否的大作文题。先看一篇 258 词的第一稿卡在哪三处,再看同一组想法改成 296 词以后怎样把「必须完成」这个要求回答清楚。
Some people think that secondary schools should require every student to complete a fixed number of hours of unpaid work in the local community before they can graduate. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
In many countries, young people spend most of their time studying and have little contact with the community around them. Some people think that secondary schools should require every student to complete a fixed number of hours of unpaid work in the local community before they can graduate. I agree with this idea because volunteering is good for young people and for society.
First of all, unpaid work helps students to grow as people. Community service teaches students responsibility and improves their communication skills. For example, students can visit a care home for elderly people, clean a local park or help in a library at the weekend. These activities are very different from sitting in a classroom, and students can learn many things that are not in their textbooks.
Secondly, the community also benefits from this work. Many local organisations do not have enough money to pay staff, so they need extra help. If every student in a school gives some hours each year, a lot of useful work will be done. Some people say that students are too busy with examinations, but I think they can always find time if they manage it well. Teenagers spend many hours on their phones every day, so a few hours of service is not a big problem.
In conclusion, I agree that students should do unpaid work in the community. It is good for their personal development and it helps local people as well. Schools and parents should encourage teenagers to take part in these activities as much as possible.
I agree with this idea because volunteering is good for young people and for society.
题目问的是学校该不该把社区服务定为毕业的硬性要求,这句话回答的是志愿服务好不好。全文没有解释为什么要强制,结尾还换成了 encourage,读者看不出作者同意的是「要求」还是「鼓励」。
怎么改 把理由对准 require:说明自愿参加时哪一类学生会缺席,强制要求能给这类学生带来什么。开头和结尾用同一个词表态。
Community service teaches students responsibility and improves their communication skills.
好处只有结论。读者不知道哪一种服务、通过什么过程让学生变得有责任感,后面的养老院、公园和图书馆只是活动名称,没有接回这句话。
怎么改 选一种服务和一类学生写完整:学生每次具体做什么,谁在等他,失约会怎样,他因此练到了什么。
Some people say that students are too busy with examinations, but I think they can always find time if they manage it well.
反对一方最有力的理由被一句话带过。毕业班学生的时间到底紧到什么程度,文中没有写,读者会觉得作者没有认真考虑代价,同意的程度也就没有边界。
怎么改 用一段承认这个代价,写出它落在哪一类学生身上,再给出让要求仍然可行的条件,例如总时数和完成的年级。
Some people think that secondary schools should make a fixed number of hours of unpaid community work a condition of graduating. I largely agree with this requirement, because the students who would gain most from such work are the ones least likely to choose it, provided that the hours are modest and kept away from the final examination year.
开头 第二句直接回答题目里的 require:同意的是 this requirement,理由是最需要这种经历的学生最少主动参加。provided that 之后写出了同意的边界,修的是第一稿里立场对不上题目的问题。
The main reason for making service compulsory is that voluntary schemes reach only the students who are already willing. A confident teenager whose parents volunteer will sign up anyway, while a shy student who spends every weekend at home will not. Yet it is the second student who learns most. If she reads to residents of a care home every Saturday morning, someone is waiting for her at a fixed time, and letting that person down has a visible cost. This is how service teaches responsibility. She also has to start conversations with people sixty years older than her, which is practice that a classroom rarely offers. The care home, which has a small budget, gains regular help as well.
同意的部分 这一段先讲为什么要强制(voluntary schemes 只能吸引本来就愿意的学生),再用一个内向学生每周六去养老院读书的例子写出责任感是怎样来的:有人在固定时间等她,失约的后果看得见。第一稿里只有结论的那句话在这里有了过程。
However, the requirement has a real cost in time. A pupil preparing for final examinations already studies in the evenings and at weekends, and forty hours of service in that year would be taken from revision or sleep. For this reason, schools should set a modest total, for example thirty hours spread over the earlier years, and let students choose placements that fit their timetable.
边界 第一稿用一句话带过的时间问题,在这里占了一整段:先承认代价(a real cost in time),写出它落在毕业班学生身上,占掉的是复习或睡觉的时间,再给出两个条件,即总时数不多、放在低年级完成。
In conclusion, I agree that unpaid community work should be required for graduation, because only a requirement reaches the students who would never try it otherwise. My agreement depends on the hours being limited and completed before the examination year, so that service adds to their education instead of competing with it.
结尾 结尾用的词和开头一致(required、requirement),同意的对象没有变。第二句重申两个条件,同意到什么程度在这里说完。全段只做收束,论点都来自前文。
改后的一稿和第一稿用的是同一组想法,差别在三处:理由从「志愿服务好」改成了「为什么要强制」,责任感有了一个具体的形成过程,时间代价从一句话变成了一段并换来两个条件。同意与否的题目,要回答题目里的每一个关键词,并写清楚同意到哪里为止。
正在打开题目
只写 volunteering is good,会忽略 unpaid、compulsory 和 student workload 的争议。
下面三道题都问同意与否。先圈出题目里的限定词,比如 compulsory、all、only,你的立场要回答到这个词。
点开就是题目和模板,现在就能写。登录后检查通过可以获取评分,每个账号可以免费评一篇。