半分写作

雅思逻辑断了,就从立场→解释→例子接起

雅思逻辑断,多半断在主体段中间:立场写完就给例子,中间的解释空着。逐段检查「立场→解释→例子」,断在哪一环,下一版就只改那一环。下面先看 5 组改前改后的段落,再看一条逐句标好角色的完整逻辑链。

作者:Hans · 更新于 每个问题都对应一个具体的写作步骤。
评分标准

主体段的逻辑,指读者能沿着一条线从立场走到段尾,每个原因都写在纸上。断在任意一环,Coherence 就从那一环开始变弱。

  • 这样写读起来

    Working from home makes employees more productive. For example, many large companies now have offices in several countries. This shows that remote work benefits businesses.

    改成这样

    Working from home makes employees more productive, because they lose the commute and the constant interruptions of an open office. A software firm in my city, for example, reported that its developers finished tasks a day earlier on average after it moved to remote work. The gain comes from uninterrupted time rather than from the location itself.

    例子说的是公司开分部,与在家办公的效率是两回事;先补解释(省通勤、少打断),例子再证明它。

  • 这样写读起来

    Governments should invest more in public transport. In Tokyo, the rail network carries millions of passengers every day. Therefore, public transport deserves more funding.

    改成这样

    Governments should invest more in public transport, because a reliable network gives people a real alternative to driving, which cuts congestion and emissions at the same time. Tokyo illustrates this: its rail system carries millions of passengers a day, and car ownership in the city centre stays low as a result. Funding that keeps the network reliable is what turns the alternative into a habit.

    立场和例子之间缺少解释:东京为什么能证明政府该投钱?补上「可靠的网络让人放下车钥匙」这一层,例子才有指向。

  • 这样写读起来

    Advertising aimed at children should be banned because it encourages unhealthy eating. For instance, children spend several hours a day watching videos online. This proves that advertising harms them.

    改成这样

    Advertising aimed at children should be banned because it encourages unhealthy eating. Children lack the experience to see that a cartoon character selling cereal is a sales technique, so they ask for the product as if a friend had recommended it. Studies of primary-school pupils have found that those shown a snack advertisement chose that snack far more often at lunch than those shown a toy advertisement. The ban targets the link between the message and the choice.

    看视频时间长,证明的是「接触多」,而立场说的是「吃得差」;例子要对准立场里的那个结果。

  • 这样写读起来

    Many people now shop online instead of visiting local stores. Online shops offer a wide range of products at low prices. Therefore, local communities are becoming weaker.

    改成这样

    Many people now shop online instead of visiting local stores, since online shops offer a wider range at lower prices. As customers move online, local shops lose the income that kept them open, and when they close, the street loses the places where neighbours used to meet. Local communities grow weaker because those meeting places disappear with the shops.

    Therefore 前面只有「网购便宜」,推到「社区变弱」中间缺了两步:店铺倒闭、见面场所消失。因果每一步都要写出来。

  • 这样写读起来

    Studying abroad helps young people become independent. It also improves their career prospects. These are the main reasons why more students choose to study overseas.

    改成这样

    Studying abroad helps young people become independent, because for the first time they handle rent, cooking and paperwork with their parents far away. A friend who moved to Melbourne for her degree learned within a month to manage a budget and negotiate with a landlord, tasks her parents had always handled. That independence, rather than the certificate, is what most graduates say the year abroad gave them.

    两个立场并排放着,每个都只有一句,读者得自己找理由。一段只留一个立场,用解释和例子把它写满。

一条完整的逻辑链:逐句标出角色

Public libraries still deserve government funding, because they give low-income families free access to books, computers and a quiet place to study. In my city, for example, the central library runs evening homework sessions, and most of the pupils who attend come from families who rely on its computers. Funding libraries therefore keeps a study space open to the people who need it most.

  • 立场:Public libraries still deserve government funding,直接回答题目。
  • 解释:because 后面写为什么成立,低收入家庭在这里免费用到书、电脑和安静的座位。
  • 例子:晚间作业班里多是靠图书馆电脑学习的孩子,证明的正是上一句的解释。
  • 回扣:therefore 把例子推回立场,结论和第一句说的是同一件事。

怎样在自己的段落里找到断点

给主体段的每一句标上角色:立场、解释、例子、回扣,再看四个角色是否齐全、顺序是否对。找到断点后,只在那一格动笔,其他句子先放着。

  • 四个角色是否各有一句?
  • 例子是否服务它前面那句解释?
  • 末句是否回到第一句的立场?

because 和 therefore 测试

在立场和下一句之间默念 because,在例子和末句之间默念 therefore,读得顺,链条就闭合了。读着卡顿的那一句在换话题,推出其他结论的例子需要换。

  • 立场 + because + 第二句,读起来是否成立?
  • 例子 + therefore + 末句,推出的是否就是立场?

每一稿只改一处

每一稿只改主体段里真正断开的那一处,改完重读整段。下一篇同类题再查同一个位置,断点消失了就换下一个。

下一步

用自己的几句英文检查这一项

写 2–3 句英文拿一份反馈,再按本页的检查点改一版。游客也能试,登录后保留记录。